In discussing the nations who are permitted to marry into Am Yisrael, we are taught that Ammon and Moav are prohibited because they did not greet us with bread and water and they hired Bilaam to curse us. However, the nations of Edom and Mitzrayim are permitted after three generations (23:4–8). Surely, this is very perplexing. After all, didn’t these nations treat us harshly as well? Wasn’t Edom the nation that denied us access into their country, even though we promised to purchase food and drink from them, and even threatened to wage war on us? Not to mention all the incredible harm that the Egyptians inflicted upon us—the brutal slavery, the throwing of the baby boys into the Nile, and so on.
The Ramban (23:4) explains that Ammon and Moav were both descended from Lot, whose life was saved by Avraham when he acted with incredible self-sacrifice to rescue him from captivity. Ammon and Moav should have shown gratitude to the descendants of the one who saved their ancestor’s life, yet instead, they harmed us. We know that the essence of the Jewish nation is gratitude, as the Midrash teaches: “We are not called Reuvenim or Shimonim, but rather Yehudim” (Bereishit Rabbah 98:6). Since this trait is the essence of a Jew, such a severe lack of gratitude is intolerable to our nation, and that is why they can never marry into us.
This is as opposed to Edom and Mitzrayim, who, although they inflicted great harm upon us, did not lack gratitude. Therefore, they are allowed to marry into us after three generations.
Rabbi Elyah Lopian (Lev Eliyahu vol. 2, p. 333) explains that the reason why this decree is eternal—and even after hundreds of generations these nations can never marry into us—is because each generation should have appreciated the fact that if not for Avraham, they wouldn’t be here. He explains that this model is a lesson for all of us: we are only in this world due to the great benevolence of Hashem. Every single second He pumps life into us, as Chazal teach, we should really thank Hashem for each breath! (Bereishit Rabbah 14:11).
Moreover, every moment He renews the world; if He were to refrain from this for even one split second, the world would revert to nothingness. As we state in davening: “Who renews in His goodness the creation of the world.” This is despite the numerous other benefits that we experience constantly: the fact that we have a never-ending supply of food, that we are healthy, that we can walk, talk, and see, that we have a roof over our heads, beds to sleep on—the list goes on and on. The hallmark of a Jew is to recognize that everything is a gift from Hashem, and we would not have anything if not for His great goodness.
This principle also applies to our feelings of gratitude toward others. There are so many people in our lives, without whom things could be very different. Our parents helped bring us into the world and raised us. We have family members, friends, teachers, and others who have benefited us in countless ways.
One freezing cold winter day, Rav Shach requested that his grandson arrange a car for him to go to a levaya in Haifa. The grandson feared for the elderly Rav’s health on such a long trip in the cold, yet Rav Shach insisted. The grandson expected it to be the levaya of a great Torah personality with thousands of people, yet to his surprise, there was barely a minyan.
When it was time to return home, Rav Shach signaled to his grandson that he wasn’t ready yet and remained standing outside in the freezing cold. When asked for an explanation, Rav Shach recounted that when he was twelve, he learned in a Yeshiva in Europe under very primitive conditions. He had to sleep on a hard bench in the freezing cold and often lacked food.
He received a letter from an uncle who was a blacksmith, asking him to work for him, promising board, sufficient food, and a fixed parnasah. His conditions were so hard that he decided to accept this offer, figuring that he would at least be able to maintain set times to learn and no longer be hungry or cold.
He was then approached by an almanah who told him that her late husband had left behind many blankets, and since she had no use for them, she wanted to give him one. This warm Russian blanket made such a big difference that he never felt so warm. He decided immediately to remain in the Yeshiva and eventually became one of the generation’s most revered Torah giants.
Rav Shach explained that all his accomplishments were due to this woman, and he felt compelled to attend her levaya. He further explained why he insisted on remaining outside in the freezing cold: “I wanted to remember how cold I felt in Yeshiva in order to fully appreciate how much this woman helped me!” (Reflections of the Magid, p. 82, Rabbi Pesach Krohn).








