NACH SUMMARY: Shmuel 10-15
10: Shmuel anoints Shaul as King and gives him orders as to what to do and
where to go, with various signs along the way. Shaul receives ‘another
heart’ and starts prophesying. Shaul is then singled out at a gathering of
all the people as the new King and Shmuel tells everyone & writes the
‘Mishpat Hamelucha’.
11. Nachash, King of the Ammonites, besieges Yavesh Gilead and offers to put
out the people’s right eyes. Shaul led the battle to defeat the Ammonites,
finishing before the heat of the day. The people have a celebration at
Gilgal and they gave the kingship to Shaul.
12. Shmuel defends his record as a leader/judge, reminds B’Y of their
history, criticises them for their sins, calls on Hashem to give signs and
warns them over the future.
13. War on Plishtim; people get scared and Shaul offers korbanot before
Shmuel arrives. Shmuel criticises Shaul for not following Hashem’s command
and says he will lose the kingship.
14. Yonatan leads a secret advance party, the main army later joins in and
the B’Y wins. Shaul declares a fast until evening, Yonatan doesn’t know
about this and eats honey, he is eventually singled out for his sin but
saved by the people; Shaul then continues fighting wars.
15. Shmuel relates to Shaul Hashem’s command to obliterate Amalek; B’Y kill
everyone bar Agag and some of the best livestock; Shmuel is angry that Shaul
has not kept Hashem’s word; Shaul originally claims it was all for offering
to Hashem but later repents and admits he shouldn’t have listened to the
people. Shmuel tells him he has been rejected as King and after that day
never sees him again.
Dvar Torah:
Shaul: A Sincere Apology?
One of the key moments of Shaul’s reign came with his failure to destroy
Agag (ancestor of Haman), King of Amalek. Shmuel told him that Hashem wanted
him to destroy everything – both people and property – of Amalek. Shaul
instead takes the King alive and intends to use the best livestock to offer
to Hashem and is convinced that this was what Hashem wanted. After an
argument with Shmuel over what exactly Hashem did want (naturally it was
that Shaul should listen to him!), Shaul repents…or does he?
He says “I have sinned for I have forsaken the word of Hashem and your word”
but in the next pasuk he says “And now, please forgive my sin and return
with me and I will bow to Hashem”. This doesn’t sound so problematic but
after Shmuel refuses and a garment is torn (representing the ‘tear’ in the
kingship), Shaul says again, this time more succinctly, “I have sinned, now
please honour me in front of my people…” It seems that Shaul is in a hurry
to get on with the show i.e. the victory celebrations with the people and he
is just apologising in order that Shmuel will appear with him ‘on stage’ and
bow to Hashem. However Shmuel does not accept the apology and after that day
he never sees his ‘talmid’ again. This episode can shed some light on why
Shaul’s punishment was so harsh (i.e. his sins were more than just mistakes)
but can also teach us a lesson in accepting when we are wrong, but also when
we do apologise, to make it sincere and not with any ulterior motive.
Shabbat Shalom
Michael
With thanks to Rav Leibtag and www.tanach.org
p.s. Aphorism of the week: “Is Shaul also among the prophets?” (Shmuel
10:12)





