When the brothers returned to Egypt with Binyamin, Yosef served for them an extravagant feast. Delicious foods were served and the finest wines flowed. A fascinating comment of Rashi tells us that at this feast was actually the first time that the brothers drank wine since Yosef was sold (43:34). Yet this calls for an explanation. Why did they suddenly drink wine now? Their abstinence of wine was an expression of mourning for the loss of Yosef yet from their perspective, Yosef was still lost?
The Netziv (Harhav Davar 43:34) brings a beautiful explanation. He explains that the reason why the brothers partook in this meal and drank wine was because they considered it to be a seudas hodayah, a meal of thanksgiving to Hashem! Originally, they were accused of being spies but now it became evident that Yosef believed their story, and was acting friendly towards them. They were so full of gratitude to Hashem that they treated this meal as a seudas hodayah, celebrating heartily and drinking wine.
In the times of the Beis Hamikdash, gratitude was expressed by bringing a korban todah, along with forty loaves and a grand feast, as a public display of gratitude. Since the brothers celebrated their seudas hodayah before the korban todah, they chose wine as a medium to express their gratitude. This is alluded to in the verse in Tehillim โI will raise up the cup of salvation and call out in the name of Hashemโ (116:12). Wine is considered a distinguished beverage, so drinking it at a public gathering can be a great way of expressing gratitude. (Haemek Davar 43:34)
The brothers’ salvation wasn’t fully complete. They still havenโt returned home with Binyamin and Shimon, and as we know, on their way home they were falsely accused again. Yet they were still full of gratitude that things started to turn in their favor. We see the importance of expressing gratitude for a salvation, even if it is only the beginning and hasnโt fully come into fruition. (Based on Drash Moshe part 2. p.23)
Making a public display of gratitude is a key aspect of Chanukah. We donโt just commemorate the great salvation that happened to ourselves but we try and ensure that we publicly thank Hashem for this, known as pirsumai nisa, publicizing the miracle.
This has many halachic ramifications. For example, the candles should be placed in a public area and can be lit whenever people are still outside. Additionally, even though everyone lights at home, we also light in Shul to publicize the miracle even more. If one only has the option to purchase wine for kiddush or oil for the candles, he should purchase oil since pirsumei nisa is more important.
From the above examples, we see how pirsumei nisa plays a vital role in the laws of candle lighting, as it is the essence of Chanukah. It is not enough that we feel gratitude for the incredible salvation, but we must publicize the miracle; spreading Hashemโs incredible goodness to the world.
We can make use of this idea in our own lives too. Whenever we experience a salvation, we can make a reminder of this as a way of publicizing this to whoever sees. As we see in the following moving story.
There was once a gabbai tzedakah who was sent by his community in Eretz Yisrael to Europe to raise funds. When he visited Italy, he was hosted by a distinguished philanthropist who lived in an extravagant mansion. The gabbai tzedakah was overwhelmed by the opulence of his home. The chandeliers were made of the finest crystal, there were intricate tapestries and ornate marble floors. He noticed that in the breakfront there was a beautiful solid gold Menorah, but to his surprise there were some broken pieces of a glass bottle lying next to it. โWhy are there broken bottle pieces in your breakfront?โ he asked his host curiously, โthey look very out of place in such a well-kept home.โ โWell, I would like you to know that they are the most important thing in this house,โ the host replied. โEverything I have is because of these bottles.โ
The host went on to explain that he was learning very well in Yeshivah when he was younger, and he planned to continue for a long time. One day, he received a letter from his grandfather telling him that the family business was struggling and asking for him to come and help. He decided to leave Yeshivah temporarily and to assist his grandfather. Unfortunately, his grandfather passed away suddenly from a heart attack, leaving him to singlehandedly run the business. He opened many new branches and the business skyrocketed. However, his dedication to his Judaism began to dwindle and he eventually left the path of Torah.
One day, as he was walking down the street, he saw a young boy crying inconsolably. โWhy are you crying?โ he asked. The boy explained that he was from a poverty-stricken home and his father saved up penny by penny for months in order to purchase oil for Chanukah. He was sent to purchase the oil and tried very hard to ensure he would not drop the bottle, yet he suddenly was startled by a cat and the bottle broke into smithereens. โWhat will I tell my father?โ the boy sobbed, โHow can I go home without the oil?โ The Italian businessman had compassion and bought him another bottle. The words of the boy kept on ringing in his head for days: โWhat will I tell my father, what will I tell him?โ He thought to himself, โWhat will I tell my Father in Heaven, He has been so good to me and entrusted me with such a pure neshamah, how could I have rebelled against Him?โ He slowly began his path back to religious observance, eventually becoming fully Torah observant. He kept the glass pieces on public display as a reminder of how Hashem helped bring him back to the path of Torah.






