The Jewish calendar is filled with many fun and exciting holidays, which add so much joy and meaning to our lives. Yet, when the three weeks come around, we are met with strict laws and restrictions. We can’t have haircuts, weddings, listen to music, and when the nine days begin the restrictions become more stringent. This is a time of year that can be challenging to relate to, and we might have a tendency to wish that we could just finish with this period and enjoy our summer.
Yet, despite the challenges of this period, this is actually an incredibly meaningful time where we can draw very close to Hashem. In fact, the potential for spiritual growth on Tishah Be’Av is no less than on Yom Kippur!
We also find that there are twenty-one days from Rosh Hashanah to Hoshanah Rabah—this is such a unique period where we can draw close to Hashem and achieve atonement for our sins. These days parallel the twenty-one days between Shivah Asar BeTamuz and Tishah Be’Av, which is also a unique period when we can become forgiven for all our sins.
When we strengthen our Avodas Hashem during these days and overcome the temptations of the yetzer hara, we can merit a special closeness to Hashem. One teaching draws an allusion from the verse, “Kol rodfeha hisiguha bein hametzarim”—which can be understood as, “Anyone who pursues Hashem can reach Him during the Bein Hametzarim.”
How could such a challenging time, when we mourn and focus on the calamities that happened to Klal Yisrael, also be a time of great closeness to Hashem? This can be understood through a parable:
A powerful king, when he resides in his palace, is inaccessible to the masses. Of course, no one can just walk in and have an audience with the king. After all, his palace is surrounded by a moat and guarded heavily. Yet, occasionally the king will travel through his kingdom and pass through the countryside, giving all the simple peasants a chance to observe him. Now the king is so much more accessible, riding his chariot with only a few guards. It’s a very different scene from the restricted palace.
Nowadays, the Shechinah is in exile, and is therefore very accessible to us. When a person feels the pain of the Shechinah in exile and is pained by it, Hashem draws close to him. So, the Bein Hametzarim, when we mourn the destruction of the Beis Hamikdash and our exile, is actually an opportune time for closeness to Hashem.
It’s been taught that in every exile the Shechinah goes into exile with us. When we were exiled to Egypt, the Shechinah was with us. When we were exiled to Bavel, the Shechinah was with us. And in the future, when we will be redeemed, the Shechinah will be redeemed along with us.
This sheds light upon the idea of closeness during exile. Unfortunately, we are exiled, yet the Shechinah is here with us, affording us a special, unique closeness. Hashem has said that whenever a calamity befalls us and we seek Him, He will join us in our pain and immediately answer our prayers, as the verse says, “They will call out to Me and I will answer them; I am with them in their pain.”
This also explains why in the Shmoneh Esrei we say, “For Your salvation I have hoped all day.” We don’t say “our salvation,” but “Your salvation,” because Hashem feels our pain deeply and longs to redeem us. When we pray for salvation, we’re not only asking for ourselves—we’re asking for Hashem’s own longing to bring the redemption to be fulfilled. At that moment in davening, we can ask Hashem for any salvation we need.
Furthermore, in the Torah reading on Tishah Be’Av, which foretells how Klal Yisrael will sin and be exiled, the verse assures us, “For Hashem your G-D is a merciful G-D. He will not abandon you or destroy you.” Even when we are forced into exile, Hashem is right there with us, holding our hand every step of the way. Therefore, it’s very fitting that we read this on Tishah Be’Av—because when we cry, Hashem is, so to speak, crying with us. It is such a powerful moment of closeness.
In fact, it’s taught that when we sit on the ground on Tishah Be’Av, the Shechinah sits with us. It’s a special eis ratzon—a moment of divine favor—when we can pray for whatever we are lacking. Hashem, so to speak, joins us in our mourning. After all, He continues to yearn for us and for the day that we will finally be redeemed.
This also helps us understand a contradiction between two teachings. One teaching says that the Keruvim—angelic figures on the Aron Kodesh—would face each other when Klal Yisrael did Hashem’s will, and turn away when we did not. But another teaching says that when the Beis Hamikdash was destroyed and the Romans entered the Kodesh HaKodashim, the Keruvim were embracing.
How can this be? Klal Yisrael were clearly not fulfilling Hashem’s will—so why were the Keruvim embracing?
The explanation is that after the Churban, Klal Yisrael had such a deep longing to reconnect with Hashem that it stirred an overwhelming response in Heaven. This longing aroused a great eis ratzon, a special moment of divine love, reflected in the embracing Keruvim.
This connects beautifully to the theme of Shir Hashirim, which is a megillah expressing the deep love between Klal Yisrael and Hashem—written specifically for times of exile. For example, the verse, “Let Him kiss me with the kisses of His mouth,” reflects Klal Yisrael’s intense yearning to return to the deep connection we had before the destruction—like a bride and groom.
We now see that the Bein Hametzarim is truly an incredibly meaningful period and a time when we can achieve great closeness to Hashem. It is certainly not a time we should wish away. On the contrary, it’s a time when our tefillos have added strength and when learning Torah is especially powerful—because a unique abundance of Torah is being poured into the world.
Complied by Daniel Shasha, to recive our weekly Devar Torah by email: livingappreciation@gmail.com
