- ShortVort - https://www.shortvort.com/ -

The Return of the Dove

The heavens opened and it rained and rained for forty days and forty nights without stopping. The earth was covered with water but after some months the mountain tops became visible. Noach sent a raven from the ark but soon after, unable to find dry land, it returned. After the raven’s unsuccessful foray, Noach sent a dove to look for dry land. The dove was no more successful than was the raven and returned to the ark. The Torah tells us (Bereishit 8:9):

The dove found no resting place for its foot – so it returned to him [Noach] to the ark because there was water upon the entire surface of the earth – so he stretched out his hand and took it, and he brought it to him to the ark.

The Netziv (Rabbi Naftali Zvi Yehuda Berlin) notes (in his commentary Haamek Davar to Bereishit 8:9) that the Torah didn’t need to tell us this detail of Noach taking the dove into his hand, but since the Torah specifies this, there must be a lesson for us to learn. The Netziv writes that Noach was compassionate towards the dove despite the dove having failed in its mission, albeit through no fault of its own.

We learn a similar lesson from the command[1] that we mustn’t eat from a treife animal, that is an animal that was not shechted in the proper way but was killed by another animal. This instruction is written follows (Shemot 22:30):

You shall be holy people to Me, and flesh torn in the field you shall not eat – you shall throw it to the dog.

We might wonder why the Chumash tells us to throw the treife meat to the dog. We fulfil the commandment, by refraining from eating the meat – does it matter how we dispose of the meat?

Rashi says that we reward dogs, by giving them the treife meat, as dogs did the Bnei Yisrael a great service as they were about to leave Mitzrayim – not a single dog cried out[2]. Chizkuni says that the Torah does not speak of just “any dog.” It speaks of dogs which guard your flocks, and which therefore have earned this privilege. Daat Zekenim explains similarly.

The Baalei Musar ask why one would reward a dog who has failed to look after the sheep sufficiently well. After all, one of the sheep has been killed by an animal – so the dog has failed in its task – why then reward it? They answer, that sometimes we give work to workers and they don’t achieve 100% success, or they even fail to do the work adequately. Nevertheless, we must thank them for all the good work they have done for us in the past, and even for their attempts to fulfil tasks in which they fail.

We should learn from Noach welcoming the dove, and rewarding the dog that failed in its mission, that we must indeed give thanks to our workers even if they don’t achieve what we ask from them.

[Photo of turtle dove taken by Julian Alper at Gamla, Israel]

[1] Sefer HaChinuch – Mitzvah 73

[2] Shemot 11:7