Lot seems to have been quite an enigmatic character. The Midrash has mixed messages about Lot. On the one hand, Avraham is criticised for separating from Lot while at the same time encouraging others to join him[1]. On the other hand, Avraham is criticised for taking Lot with him to Israel when he made his momentous ‘Lech Lecha’ journey[2]. The Torah itself describes how Lot was welcoming towards his guests (the angels)[3] but yet willing to sacrifice his daughters to the mob in S’dom[4]. Rashi indicates that all the time Lot was with him, Avraham didn’t receive prophecy from Hashem[5], however, Lot is praised for cooperating with Avraham’s charade that Sarah was his sister[6]. In S’dom, he was like a tzadik in comparison to the other residents, he certainly showed hospitality to his guests and was even appointed a judge – but in the presence of Avraham, Lot and his workers were like reshaim and ultimately Avraham asked him to part company.
Why was it that Lot didn’t live as a complete tzadik, like his uncle, Avraham? Rav Shimon Schwab finds an answer to this question in the unusual wording in this pasuk (Bereishit 14:12)[7]:
And they [the invaders] took Lot and his possessions, the son of Avram’s brother, and they departed, and he was living in S’dom.
We would have expected the pasuk to read:
And they took Lot, the son of Avram’s brother, and his possessions, and they departed …
Instead, the pasuk reads:
And they took Lot and his possessions, the son of Avram’s brother, and they departed …
What came between Avraham and Lot? Lot’s possession, his desire for money. If it weren’t for his greed, he could have lived life as a tzadik, like Avraham.
Was Avraham right to separate from Lot? Should he have pushed Lot away? Or should he have lived with him and risked being dragged down by Lot to Lot’s level? This is always a dilemma – should one live amongst bad people to influence them to be good – or should one stay away from bad people, fearing that their influence would be bad?
Rav Dessler suggests that Avraham should have pushed himself to reach such a high level that he could withstand the bad influence of Lot and yet still be there for Lot, to help him rise higher. Similarly, says Rav Dessler, we must reach for higher levels so that we can extend our influence over others without being dragged down by those we need to help.
—
Photo of Rock Hyrax taken by Julian Alper. The Torah tells us that rock hyraxes, שפנים, are certainly not Kosher (Vayikra 11:5) despite exhibiting one of the signs of kosher animals.
ואת־השפן כי־מעלה גרה הוא ופרסה לא יפריס טמא הוא לכם
[1] Bereishit Rabbah 41:8
[2] Stone Chumash to Bereishit 12:4 quotes the Zohar Chadash saying that Avraham foresaw that David and the Mashiach would be descendants of Lot, so he felt the need to look after him.
[3] Bereishit 19:2
[4] Bereishit 19:8
[5] Rashi to Bereishit 13:14
[6] Rashi to Bereishit 19:29
[7] Bereishit 14:12
