Why no Mishnayos Chanuka? PDF Print E-mail
User Rating: / 1
PoorBest 
Holy Days - Chanukah
Written by Moshe Kormornick   
Chanuka is said to be the 'festival' of the Oral Torah, so why is there no Gemora about Chanuka? We have by Purim, Pesach, Succos, but why not by Chanuka?

Rav Nissan Kaplan shlit"a suggests a beautiful answer:

The Greeks did not try to destroy us physically, they tried to destroy our Torah - our identity. So, when it was time for Rebbe to write down the Mishnayos due to fear that the Jewish People would start to forget the Oral Torah, to some extent, the Greeks had succeeded. They had taken our Oral Torah and to a degree, reduced it. So, when it came to Chanuka, the time when we celebrate our success over the Greeks and their values, Rebbe could not let Chanuka be written down into Mishnayos, Chaunka had to remain as the Oral Torah in its unchanged form. So even though the Greeks succeeded in a way, by causing our Oral Torah to be written down, at least when it came to Chanuka, the 'festival of the Oral Torah', that would have to be learned totally orally without any Mishnayos.
This is a comment on "Chanukah"
 

Show Other Articles Of This Author

Sign Up Here

Free Weekly Parsha PageSubscribeVort of the Week, Question of the Week, Video of the Week...and more!
Email Address

Sponsored Links - Please Visit our Patrons

Jerusalem Balloons

Reliable Web Hosting

 

Send us YOUR vort here

Weekly Parsha

Torah Portion

 

Click here to read about the Parasha

To sponsor this website or to advertise to the thousands of people that see ShortVort.com every month or hundreds that receive the weekly email contact moishe@shortvort.com

Site Dedication

This website is dedicated to the memories of

Moshe Shlomo ben R'Shmuel | Shlomo ben R'Chaim | Aryeh Leib ben Pinchas Tzvi

Click here to sponsor a dedication

 

Contact us | Advertising | Disclaimer | Sitemap