Print This Post Print This Post

Brochos 2a questions in shas!

Written by Benjamin Rose

Learning Gemara can spring up some very obvious questions. When learning Brachos 2a the most obvious question of all is: ‘Why does the Mishnah choose the reading of Sh’ma at night to be the very first halacha to be discussed in Shas?’ Tosafos (Shabbos 2a) notes that many masechtos are arranged according to the order in which the events of a particular day occur. For example, Massechta Pesachim begins with the laws of bedikas chametz, which is a full day before the festival of Pesach actually begins. The massechta then deals with the slaughtering of the korban Pesach, which is the afternoon before the chag, and it finally progresses to the holiday and its laws. Yoma also begins with the preparations of the Kohen Gadol a week before Yom Kippur, and it progresses sequentially through the actions of the Kohen the day before Yom Kippur, and finally we are introduced to the service of the day itself.

Similarly, here, when a person becomes barmitzvah, his obligation to fulfill mitzvos begins as night falls, and the first mitzvah anyone ever has the obligation to fulfill is the reading of Shema that night, as he concludes his twelve year and enters into his thirteenth year. In fact, the verse itself is structured to reflect this, as the Torah instructs us to read Shema “as you lay down and as you awaken.” (Devarim 6:7).

That’s why we we learn the halacha of when to read the shema at night time in the first mishna in shas!

Leave a Comment